Connect with us

In the first installment of the Position Battles, I am going to look at the NL position battles going on around Spring Training.  Check out the AL Position Battles as well.

Every year there are battles that take place, some more intriguing than others. Well this year is no different. Most of these teams have real questions in their rotations. Others hoping some young kids can take over their positions.

Most of the time managers look to try a new lineup configuration, getting to know new acquisitions. Pitchers will try to perfect new pitches and get their command down before the games start to count. We, as Fantasy Baseball owners, look at these battles and hope they resolve themselves before our annual draft.

Now let’s take a look at how I see these teams addressing their battles.

NL Position Battles

National League
Team Position Expected Starter Warming the Bench Notes
Arizona Diamondbacks 2B Brandon Drury Daniel Descalso

Nick Ahmed

After the Jean Segura trade, there is an opening at second base for Arizona. Brandon Drury looks like it is his job to lose. Drury, just 24 years-old, has the kind of bat that makes a manager want to get him into the lineup. It could go a long way to helping the Diamondbacks get some more power in the lineup to compliment Paul Goldschmidt, Jake Lamb and Yasmany Tomas. If Drury cannot take the job and run with it, Daniel Descalso or Nick Ahmed would slot in as a safer, more defensive minded second baseman.
Atlanta Braves P Mike Foltynewicz Matt Wisler

Aaron Blair

Lucas Sims

Sean Newcomb

The Braves went out and got veteran pitchers for the rotation, much to the chagrin of the young starters not named Julio Teheran. Atlanta added ageless wonder Bartolo Colon, R.A. Dickey and through a trade with the Cardinals, Jaime Garcia. That leaves the last spot open for some young guns to take. As of right now, Mike Foltynewicz has the upper hand. But he will be pushed by several pitchers in Spring Training, which include Matt Wisler, Aaron Blair, Lucas Sims and dark horse Sean Newcomb? I predict Newcomb gets a shot, but ultimately he will go back to Triple-A. The Braves will not want to shake the confidence of one of their Top 5 prospects.

Update: Blair gave up one run in 2.2 innings after missing some time with a bruised left hand he suffered in his last start. He also allowed five hits, struck out one and walked a batter. So far it looks like Folty is holding off the other young players for the fifth starter spot. Wisler and Blair could be mid-season callups or injury fill-ins if needed. Sims is a long shot and the Braves re-assigned Newcomb to minor league camp on Thursday.

Chicago Cubs 2B/OF/P 2B:

Ben Zobrist


Kyle Schwarber


Mike Montgomery


Javier Baez


Ben Zobrist


Brett Anderson

Having the Cubs problems are good problems to have. How are we going to get all of these bats in the lineup? Joe Maddon did a great job last year on the way to a World Series victory. But how will that success impact this year? Last year, Kyle Schwarber went down with an injury that may have been a blessing. It allowed Baez to get more run on the diamond. For strictly defensive purposes, having Javier Baez at second base and moving Ben Zobrist to left field would be ideal. And that does not mean they lack the firepower making that move. But the Cubs organization love Schwarber’s bat. So I see Zobrist at second, Schwarber in left field and Baez back in a super utility role.

As far as the fifth starter, the Cubs are hoping that Mike Montgomery can fill that void, since the oft injured Brett Anderson cannot be counted on. Chicago hopes an internal option emerges so they do not have to pay for a rental in the summer trying to repeat as champions.

Cincinnati Reds





Rasiel Iglesias


Robert Stephenson


Michael Lorenzen

Tony Cingrani

Drew Storen


Amir Garrett

Right now, the Reds have many arms in the bullpen they thought would be staples of their rotation. Alas, Rasiel Iglesias, Michael Lorenzen and Tony Cingrani are all going to be a part of a committee approach at closer. Drew Storen is also in that mix. Maybe one can emerge to hold the job down, but this looks like a messy situation going forward.

As for the fifth starter, Robert Stephenson looked to be the early favorite for the spot. Although he just got roughed up in his latest start. That could open things up for the college basketball player turned pitcher Amir Garrett. He looks to have an outside shot for the rotation. At Double A-Pensacola last season, Garrett had an ERA of 1.75 with 78 strikeouts in 77 innings pitched. That type of swing and miss stuff could be intriguing enough to land him in Cincinnati to begin the season.

Update: Garrett, in his first two spring games, has struck out four, walked one batter and allowed one run in 4.2 innings. However, in his start Wednesday, Garrett allowed five unearned runs on seven hits and a walk in 2.2 innings. He also had a wild pitch and committed two errors on the same play. Although the runs were unearned, they came as a result of his errors. Bryan Price said he hasn’t eliminated any of the main candidates for a spot in the rotation.

Colorado Rockies P Jeff Hoffman German Marquez This race is between two pitchers; Jeff Hoffman and German Marquez. Hoffman was part of the trade that sent Troy Tulowitzki to Toronto. He didn’t show great last year, but many can’t while working in Coors Field. Marquez is quite the opposite. He was not the big name pitcher Hoffman was, but he moved quickly through the minors to garner a September callup. As of now, whoever wins this job will only be serviceable in NL-only, or the deepest of leagues.
Los Angeles Dodgers OF Andrew Toles

Yasiel Puig

Kike Hernandez

Andre Ethier

Scott Van Slyke

Franklin Gutierrez.

Once again the Dodgers outfield is a muddled mess. The only sure player to start every day is Joc Pederson in center. Right now it looks to be Andrew Toles in left field and Yasiel Puig in right. But even I would write those in pencil. Then you also have Kike Hernandez, Andre Ethier, Scott Van Slyke and newly acquired Franklin Gutierrez.

Update: Gutierrez is hitless in 16 at-bats this spring. He will need to put some hits together soon or he could be in a platoon situation, or off the 25-man roster all together.

Miami Marlins P Adam Conley

Tom Koehler

Jose Urena

Jeff Locke

Juan Nicolino

After the unfortunate and untimely passing of Jose Fernandez, the Marlins try to piece together a rotation. Edinson Volquez is a mortal lock for the rotation, barring injury. Same goes with Wei-Yen Chen and Dan Straily. After those three you have Adam Conley, Jose Urena and Tom Koehler vying for the last two spots. Longer shots to make the rotation are Jeff Locke and Justin Nicolino. The only thing that makes this a little interesting, are the options still remaining for Conley and Koehler. Maybe that plays into the Marlins’ plans.

Update: Urena has a 6.00 ERA in three innings pitched this spring. He does have four strikeouts as well. He is probably going to be in the pen for long relief. But with Koehler  (4.76 ERA in 5.2 innings; three strikeouts) and Conley (12.00 ERA in 3.0 innings; one strikeout) struggling, it might be close. Nicolino has a 12.46 ERA in 4.1 innings with one strikeout.

Milwaukee Brewers P Chase Anderson

Wily Peralta

Tommy Milone

Jimmy Nelson


The Brewers are just counting the days until they finally bring up top pitching prospect Josh Hader. As of now, incumbent Matt Garza, Junior Guerra and Zach Davies should hold spots on opening day. I believe Taylor Jungmann will be in the bullpen after his disastrous year last year. Davies and Guerra are the most likely Fantasy starters you want to employ. And if you can wait and stash, or you play dynasty, snag Hader, who has real ‘Ace’ upside.
New York Mets OF Jay Bruce


Michael Conforto

Brandon Nimmo

Currently it is Yoenis Cespedes in left, Curtis Granderson in center, and a Jay Bruce/Michael Conforto platoon in right. The recent Lucas Duda news may just untangle the mess of an outfield the Mets currently have. Bruce has been getting some work at first base, taking ground balls and trying to get comfortable. Even with this news, the Mets also have Brandon Nimmo who could make things interesting if he plays well. Look for Bruce to be someone that could be moved if the Mets do not live up to expectations this year.

Update: All parties are hitting well. Bruce is hitting .417 with a home run and five RBIs. Conforto is batting .360 with two home runs, three RBIs and a stolen base. Nimmo is batting .476 with one RBI. The way it’s going, Bruce is still the favorite to start, with the other two going to Triple-A. A trade would help sort this situation out, as Conforto is the future in New York.

Philadelphia Phillies SS Freddy Galvis J.P Crawford This one is more of a ‘hold the spot for the Phenom’, type of situation. J.P. Crawford is the Phillies top prospect. He did not have a great 2016 season. In 123 games between Double-A and Triple-A, Crawford hit .250/.349/.339 with seven home runs and 43 RBIs to his credit. Freddy Galvis has the position right now, but he is no threat to hold onto the job once Crawford heats up. It’s just a matter of when for the youngster.
Pittsburgh Pirates P Chad Kuhl

Tyler Glasnow

Drew Hutchison

Steven Brault

This one looks like more of a competition than I believe it is. If Tyler Glasnow pitches well, he will join his rotation mate from Indianapolis, Jameson Taillon. And after he struck out six Orioles regulars in two innings on February 26, I think he’s making a great case for himself. Other pitchers that could rival Glasnow for the spot is Drew Hutchison, Chad Kuhl and Steven Brault. In the end, I see Glasnow securing the spot, and the others being injury fill ins or in long relief roles.

Update: Glasnow was roughed up by the Dominican Republic squad to the tune of six earned runs on five hits. The real issue was the four walks in the 2.1 innings pitched. Meanwhile, Hutchison struck out four in three clean frames, albeit against the Orioles backups. Brault pitched three scoreless out of the pen, and Kuhl struck out three in two scoreless against the Red Sox. If Glasnow doesn’t get the walks under control, he will find himself in Triple-A to start the year.

San Diego Padres P Christian Friedrich

Jarred Cosart

Luis Perdomo

Trevor Cahill

Zach Lee

Tyrell Jenkins

This situation is among the worst I have ever seen. Jhoulys Chacin, Clayton Richard and newly signed Jered Weaver are probably starters come the new season. But Weaver isn’t necessarily a beacon of health. The other two, there’s not exactly a lot of faith there. Then you have Christian Friedrich, Luis Perdomo, Jarred Cosart, Trevor Cahill, Zach Lee or Tyrell Jenkins. There may be even more vying for a position, but in the end, this could go a multitude of ways.
San Francisco Giants P Matt Cain Ty Blach

Tyler Beede

Albert Suarez

Looking at the roster, Matt Cain would look to be the favorite. But he hasn’t exactly done well with his opportunities. His last good season was in 2012 when he was an All-Star. Right now it looks like Ty Blach, Tyler Beede and Albert Suarez as a long shot. My money would be on Blach to come out of this competition. Beede has the most upside, but having never pitched above the Double-A level, he needs more time in the minors.

Update: Cain pitched 3.1 innings, giving up two runs on two hits. Blach continues to impress with another solid outing with two strikeouts in 2.2 frames of shutout ball against the Indians. Cain is going to have every opportunity to get the fifth starter job, but Blach may just force their hand if he can keep this type of pitching up.

St. Louis Cardinals P Michael Wacha Trevor Rosenthal

Luke Weaver

The Cardinals were dealt a real blow to their rotation when Alex Reyes had to undergo Tommy John surgery. Now it will be between Luke Weaver, Michael Wacha and Trevor Rosenthal, who is being stretched out this spring to be a starter after losing his ninth inning role. Wacha just might seize the opportunity. He was once a part of the rotation, and did well in 2015 when he went 17-7 with a 3.38 ERA. Then in 2016, the wheels came off. He went 7-7 with a 5.09 ERA. He’s already been there before; it’s just a matter if he can recapture what he once had.

Update: Weaver was pulled from a start due to back spasms. He is scheduled to throw a bullpen session on Monday the Mar 13. Wacha is still in the lead for the rotation spot. And after throwing another three scoreless innings, it looks like he’s going to lock it up. Especially with Rosenthal not slated to pitch until this weekend.

Washington Nationals Closer Shawn Kelley Joe Blanton

Blake Treinen

Trevor Gott

Koda Glover

Well the Nationals added to their bullpen depth when they signed Joe Blanton. But that just means it is another pitcher that is not guaranteed the ninth inning. Blanton will more than likely settle into the setup role. That leaves Shawn Kelley in the closer role for now. Other options include Blake Treinen, Trevor Gott and sleeper Koda Glover that could possibly take over the role should Kelley falter. All of this means nothing if Washington goes and gets an established closer at the trade deadline, just like they did last year with Mark Melancon.

Update: While Kelley is still the front-runner for the closer job, Glover is doing what he can to make it interesting. Glover now has seven strikeouts and zero earned runs in three innings this spring. Dusty Baker has said he will not use a committee, and Glover does not have the experience that Kelley does. But if this type of production continues, he just might find himself in the closers role sooner rather than later.


So there are all of the NL position battles for Spring Training. Which ones are you most interested in tracking this spring? Hit us up in the comments.

What’s the best Fantasy Baseball draft tool ever created? Check out the details right here provided by David Gonos, where he discusses in great detail, the Draft Wizard and Draft Assistant. Voted the best Fantasy Baseball draft tool for 2017, the FantasyPros’ Draft Wizard is all you need for a successful draft, as well as in-season management, on your way to a championship.

2017 Fantasy Baseball Draft Kit
Fantasy Baseball Rankings | Sleepers & Busts | Player Analysis | Draft Strategy | Spring Training Updates | Mock Drafts | Fantasy Baseball Tools

More in 2017 Fantasy Baseball Draft Kit